Tracey Tremayne-Lloyd: The Dutch public-private health-care mannequin is the repair Canada wants

Canada ought to look overseas for options, particularly to the Netherlands

Article content material

Canada’s present mannequin for offering well being care is unsustainable. Regardless of having one of many highest per-capita spending ranges amongst developed nations, lengthy wait occasions, overcrowded emergency departments and a scarcity of household docs are plaguing most communities throughout the nation.

Commercial 2

Article content material

And issues will solely worsen. Simply ask Dr. Katharine Sensible, president of the Canadian Medical Affiliation (CMA). She just lately instructed CTV Information that, “What’s clearly coming is the collapse of the present health-care system.” What “we’re not seeing,” she continued, “is the political will to take that significantly.”

As a substitute of taking the tough steps to handle the structural issues on the core of our health-care woes, federal and provincial governments appear content material to maintain medicare lingering on life assist, regardless of the struggling it causes.

Canada ought to as a substitute look overseas for options, particularly to the Netherlands. The land that gave us the telescope, Bluetooth and the primary fashionable market-oriented financial system has a health-care system that is extensively considered among the finest on this planet.

Commercial 3

Article content material

As with Canadian medicare, Dutch well being care relies on the concept that each citizen is entitled to well being providers. However as a substitute of the federal government funding it solely by way of taxes, its multi-payer system requires individuals to buy well being protection from personal insurers.

These companies, most of that are setup as not-for-profit co-operatives, are required to just accept all candidates. Income are allotted to reserves, or returned within the type of decrease premiums. Customary advantages embrace hospital stays, entry to a doctor, in-home nursing care and pharmaceuticals. Whereas adults pay premiums, annual deductibles and co-payments for the advantages they obtain, the federal government pays for kids as much as the age of 18.

Commercial 4

Article content material

Personal insurers negotiate with health-care suppliers over funding strategies and different issues, which ends up in more cost effective remedy for his or her shoppers. Dutch residents also can store round between insurers, on the lookout for the service and premium stage they need and might afford.

Uninsured adults in Holland are fined and their insurance coverage premiums could also be levied instantly from their paychecks. And the small share of the Dutch individuals who rigorously object to medical health insurance can decide out if they comply with make necessary contributions right into a well being financial savings account.

This mix of personal and public health-care funding has received reward from many corners. Dr. Robert Ouellet, past-president of the CMA, has stated that since insurance coverage firms can’t refuse to tackle new shoppers, “the result’s each affected person is on the identical stage and has the identical significance, as a result of the cash follows the affected person. What they’re doing is what they name ‘managed’ competitors.”

Commercial 5

Article content material

I consider most Canadians would agree that our bloated medicare system wants an injection of competitors to develop into vibrant and wholesome. I frequently hear from my shoppers — docs, surgeons and different well being professionals on the entrance strains — concerning the growing workloads they face as Canada tries to protect an antiquated health-care system that’s failing at virtually each stage.

The Dutch mannequin, then again, is successful near-universal reward. For instance, Dr. Paul Woods, the previous president and CEO of London Well being Sciences Centre, famous that the Netherlands “has an unbelievable major care mannequin, the place in case you have a necessity, you’ll be able to decide up the cellphone and have that want happy instantly, whether or not it is a telehealth go to or after hours … the usual Canadian reply to a necessity at 2 am is to go to emergency, which is a horrible reply.”

Commercial 6

Article content material

Dutch normal practitioners are required to supply a minimum of 50 hours of service between 5 pm and eight am yearly, to be able to keep their skilled licenses. That is why 61.5 per cent of individuals within the Netherlands say they will get an appointment with a physician or nurse both the identical day or the subsequent, as in comparison with 34.7 per cent of Canadians.

When requested if Canada must spend greater than the ten.8 per cent of GDP on well being care, Woods replied, “Possibly we do have to spend extra, however we positively have to spend it in another way.”

For the sake of all Canadians, particularly the one in seven who do not actually have a household physician, a brand new method is required. The Dutch might have the mannequin Canada ought to emulate.

Nationwide Submit

Tracey Tremayne-Lloyd is a licensed specialist in well being legislation and founding father of TTL Well being Regulation.



Postmedia is dedicated to sustaining a energetic however civil discussion board for dialogue and encourage all readers to share their views on our articles. Feedback might take as much as an hour for moderation earlier than showing on the positioning. We ask you to maintain your feedback related and respectful. We’ve enabled e-mail notifications—you’ll now obtain an e-mail if you happen to obtain a reply to your remark, there may be an replace to a remark thread you observe or if a person you observe feedback. Go to our Group Tips for extra data and particulars on how you can regulate your e-mail settings.